EWP 
New York City never stops moving. But when that movement comes to a screeching halt in the form of a car accident, everything changes—fast.
Whether you’re a local commuter, an Uber driver in Queens, or a tourist crossing Broadway, a crash can leave you physically injured, emotionally shaken, and legally overwhelmed. According to NYC DOT, over 200,000 motor vehicle crashes were reported in the five boroughs in 2024 alone.
In a no-fault insurance state like New York, navigating the claims process isn’t simple. That’s why having the right car accident lawyer isn’t just helpful—it’s essential. A skilled attorney can mean the difference between a lowball settlement and full financial recovery.
Top 7 Car Accident Lawyers in NYC (2025)
Below are NYC’s most trusted, battle-tested personal injury attorneys in 2025:
1. David J. Dean – Sullivan Papain Block McGrath Coffinas & Cannavo
Known for recovering over $1 billion for victims, Dean is a legal powerhouse in serious auto and injury litigation.
2. Alan L. Fuchsberg – The Jacob Fuchsberg Law Firm
Respected for his compassionate approach and deep expertise in catastrophic injury and wrongful death cases across NYC.
3. David M. Godosky – Godosky & Gentile, P.C.
Recognized by Super Lawyers, David has built a reputation for his courtroom tenacity and client-first strategies.
4. Melisande Hill – Hill & Moin LLP
Focused on pedestrian, bicycle, and rideshare accident cases, Hill blends empathy with fierce representation.
5. Gail S. Kelner – Kelner & Kelner, P.C.
A skilled negotiator and trial veteran in catastrophic brain injury, spinal trauma, and wrongful death claims.
6. Thomas A. Moore – Kramer, Dillof, Livingston & Moore
Secured some of New York’s largest verdicts. Moore is a veteran personal injury litigator with national acclaim.
7. Devon Reiff – Law Offices of Devon Reiff
Known for aggressive negotiation in auto, truck, and motorcycle accidents. Provides hands-on attention to every case.
How to Choose the Right Car Accident Lawyer in NYC
- Local experience: Look for attorneys with NYC-specific knowledge of traffic laws and courts.
- Trial skills: Not all cases settle. Ask about court success rates and verdicts.
- Fee structure: Most work on contingency—no win, no fee. Avoid upfront fees.
- Red flags: Beware of lawyers who guarantee results or avoid your questions.
What to Do Immediately After a Car Accident in New York City
- Call 911 and check for injuries.
- Move to safety if possible.
- Get a police report: NYPD Crash Reports
- Exchange driver and insurance info.
- Take clear photos of the damage, scene, plates.
- Collect witness contact info.
- Don’t admit fault.
- Get medical care even if you feel fine.
- Notify your insurer: No-Fault NY Info
- Call a personal injury lawyer before speaking with insurers.
What You Can Claim After a Car Accident
- Medical expenses (immediate and future care)
- Lost wages & reduced earning ability
- Pain and suffering
- Emotional distress
- Vehicle and property damage
- Loss of enjoyment of life
How to Maximize Your Compensation
- Hire a lawyer as soon as possible
- Stick to your medical treatments
- Don’t post about your accident on social media
- Track and save every receipt and report
- Be honest—exaggerations can backfire
Real Case Example
Case: Pedestrian hit by Uber in Midtown, NYC
Result: $2.9 million settlement
Attorney: Melisande Hill
Source: New York Law Journal
NYC Legal & Support Resources
- Legal Aid NYC – Free legal support
- NYPD Collision Report Portal
- NY DMV MV-104 Accident Report Form
- NY No-Fault Insurance Details
Final Thoughts
An NYC car accident can disrupt your life—but the right legal support can set it straight again. Use this guide to act fast, protect your rights, and pursue what you’re truly owed.
Don’t delay. Reach out to a qualified attorney today and start the road to recovery.
